Today’s rates for all major HUD multifamily loans
Check Today's Rates →
The Difference Between Brownfield and Greenfield Developments
A brownfield development is any project built on land that has previously been developed, while a greenfield development is a project that will occupy a space that has not been previously developed.
Image by Tiago Nakamura from Unsplash.
What are Brownfield Developments?
In commercial real estate, a brownfield development is any project built on what is called a brownfield, or land that previously has been developed. For example, replacing a dated office building with a shopping center? Constructing an affordable housing community on the former site of a hospital? These would all be considered brownfield developments.
What are Greenfield Developments?
A greenfield development is exactly the opposite: a project that will occupy a space that has not been developed. A multifamily property rising on a never-before-utilized parcel would be a good example, though a more common one today would be the construction of an industrial park in distant, predominantly agricultural exurbs of a major metropolitan area.
Both types of developments have their pros and cons when it comes to affordable housing.
Brownfield Advantages
Generally more central locations
Infrastructure/transportation links in place
Larger potential financial incentives
Flexibility in design
Lower costs
Faster development timelines
Potentially high land remediation costs
Longer development timelines
Land constraints (including zoning)
Often far from urban centers where demand is highest
Infrastructure may not be in place
Negative environmental impacts
What is the difference between brownfield and greenfield developments?
The main difference between brownfield and greenfield developments is that brownfield developments are built on land that has already been developed, while greenfield developments are built on undeveloped land. Brownfield developments are generally located in more central locations, have existing infrastructure and transportation links, and may offer larger potential financial incentives.
For example, replacing a dated office building with a shopping center or constructing an affordable housing community on the former site of a hospital would both be considered brownfield developments. Greenfield developments, on the other hand, are typically built on undeveloped land, such as a new housing development in a rural area.
For more information, please see this article on the HUD Loans blog.
What are the benefits of investing in brownfield developments?
The benefits of investing in brownfield developments include generally more central locations, existing infrastructure and transportation links, and larger potential financial incentives.
According to HUD Loans, brownfield developments have the following advantages:
- Generally more central locations
- Infrastructure/transportation links in place
- Larger potential financial incentives
What are the risks associated with investing in greenfield developments?
The risks associated with investing in greenfield developments include being far from urban centers where demand is highest, lack of infrastructure, and potential negative environmental impacts.
Greenfield developments are often far from urban centers where demand is highest, meaning that the development may not be as profitable as one located closer to the city. Additionally, infrastructure may not be in place, meaning that the investor may have to pay for the installation of roads, utilities, and other infrastructure. Finally, greenfield developments may have negative environmental impacts, such as destruction of natural habitats or pollution.
What are the advantages of investing in greenfield developments?
The advantages of investing in greenfield developments include flexibility in design, lower costs, and faster development timelines.
According to this article, greenfield developments have the following advantages:
- Flexibility in design
- Lower costs
- Faster development timelines
What are the government incentives for investing in brownfield developments?
The government offers a variety of incentives for investing in brownfield developments, including tax credits, grants, and loans. For example, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) offers grants to help with the assessment, cleanup, and redevelopment of brownfield sites. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) also offers loans for brownfield redevelopment projects. HUD's Brownfield Economic Development Initiative (BEDI) provides loans of up to $1 million for the redevelopment of brownfield sites. The loans are available to state and local governments, non-profit organizations, and private developers. Additionally, HUD's Brownfields Redevelopment Program (BRP) provides loans of up to $3 million for the redevelopment of brownfield sites. The loans are available to state and local governments, non-profit organizations, and private developers.
What are the best strategies for financing brownfield and greenfield developments?
The best strategies for financing brownfield and greenfield developments depend on the specific project and the developer's goals. For brownfield developments, the most common financing strategies include grants, tax credits, and loans from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). HUD loans are available for a variety of purposes, including acquisition, rehabilitation, and new construction. For greenfield developments, the most common financing strategies include private equity, venture capital, and bank loans. Private equity and venture capital are typically used for larger projects, while bank loans are more suitable for smaller projects.
For more information on HUD loans, please visit HUD Loans Overview.